Eurogamer's asking what the best GTA is, and I've been arguing with myself about it all morning

by opNov 15, 2026, 11:29 AM
op
opAdmin
Nov 15, 2026, 11:29 AM

The Big Question: What's the best GTA?

Eurogamer kicked off their GTA Week thing with a Big Question piece: what's the best GTA? They're framing it around the run-up to November 19, throwing in some jokes about which cars will go vrrrrm best and how many dongs, on a scale of one to ten. It's a fun little prompt, and of course the article is mostly a setup to hand the question over to the readers.

I've been chewing on it for way longer than I should. My gut says San Andreas, but I don't trust that gut anymore. Half of why I love SA is the sheer sprawl of it, three cities, the countryside, the whole rags to riches arc. The other half is nostalgia for a summer where I had nothing better to do.

the real answer probably depends on when you showed up

Ask someone who started with III and Vice City is sacred. Ask someone who came in with IV and they'll tell you the physics and the story are unmatched, and honestly the Liberty City mood still hits. Ask a GTA Online lifer and they'll just say Online, which feels like a different question entirely.

GTA 5 is the weird one for me. It's the most polished, the biggest, the one everyone played. But I don't think about the story much. I think about driving around Los Santos at night with the radio on, which is a vibe, not really a game.

what's the best GTA?

That's the version of the question I keep landing on. Best is doing a lot of work there. Best story, best map, best soundtrack, best place to just exist for a few hours. Different winners for each.

Anyway, with Leonida right around the corner, the whole ranking might get shuffled in a week. That's the part I'm actually excited about. A new Vice City to argue about for the next decade. Curious where everyone else lands on this one, because I genuinely don't have a clean answer and I've stopped pretending I do.


Source: Eurogamer · Curated content.

Got a take on this?

Join the discussion. It takes about thirty seconds, and you can reply to any thread on the forum.