Pinned

Review roundup megathread — scores and verdicts

by opNov 18, 2026, 02:23 PM
op
opAdmin
Nov 18, 2026, 02:23 PM

The embargo is up — reviews are landing. This thread collects them all: scores, verdicts, and the discussion about whether the critics played the same game we've been waiting for.

Scoreboard (updated as reviews land):

  • Filling in live as outlets publish.

House rules: link the review, quote a line or two, don't paste whole articles. Watch for story spoilers in reviews — some outlets are careless; flag spoilery ones so people can read safely. And remember a 9 from an outlet you distrust and a 7 from one you like are both just numbers — the interesting part is the arguments.

Got a take on this?

Join the discussion. It takes about thirty seconds, and you can reply to any thread on the forum.