rdr dev says rockstar crunch was for execs, not bug fixes
Caught this GamesRadar piece this morning about a Red Dead Redemption dev talking about crunch at Rockstar. Apparently the crunch wasn't even about fixing bugs, it was to put on a show for executives. That's wild. I always assumed crunch was at least about getting the game out the door, but this makes it sound like it was just theater for the suits.
The dev said
"I don't want to do this"which is pretty damning. Like, imagine being told to work insane hours just so some VP can see a polished demo. Not to make the game better, not to fix actual problems, just to look good in a meeting. That's a whole different level of messed up.
Makes me think about GTA 6 and what the team is going through right now. We're all hyped for November 19th, but if the devs are being pushed to crunch for a vertical slice or a trailer or whatever, that's not cool. Rockstar has a history of this, remember the RDR2 crunch stories from a few years back? And now with GTA 6 being the biggest game ever, the pressure must be insane. I hope they've changed, but this doesn't sound great.
I know some people will say crunch is just part of game dev, but there's a difference between a final push before launch and crunching to impress executives. One is arguably necessary, the other is just ego. And if the dev is saying "I don't want to do this," that tells you it wasn't voluntary.
Does this change how you feel about preordering or supporting the game? I already preordered the Ultimate Edition, but now I'm second guessing myself. Not because I don't want the game, but because I don't want to reward bad management. What do you all think? Is crunch ever justified if it's for a good reason, or is it always bad?
Source: GamesRadar+ · Curated content.
I already dropped $99.99 on the Ultimate Edition so my break-even is locked in at roughly four bucks per hour if I play twenty hours. Crunching devs just to polish a vertical slice for some VP? That's like running MC businesses without resupplying so the map icons look busy. Zero profit per hour. Massive burnout.
"I don't want to do this"
That hits. Actual bug fixes got shelved while they put on the show. I've done enough Cayo Perico cooldown loops to know efficiency matters. Wasting human hours on executive theater is bad management. Still gonna play. My Nightclub warehouse isn't gonna stock itself.
"I don't want to do this"
Making the crew crunch for a suit's demo is bad planning. It's all risk, no cut.
ok so i've watched those two trailers a hundred times and now i'm wondering how much of that polish was just exec theater
Got a take on this?
Join the discussion. It takes about thirty seconds, and you can reply to any thread on the forum.